18th Jul, 2008

Furthest North!

Holding Back the Tide is operating across the three coastal counties of East Anglia: Essex, Suffolk and Norfolk. And CoastNet is very pleased to welcome on board Scratby Coastal Erosion Group and Ormesby Junior School who will be working in conjunction on the project as our most northerly communities located just north of Great Yarmouth.

Scratby was first developed for holiday homes in 1934 and has maintained a strong seaside and residential identity over time . However, this cliff-top community is now facing the ultimate tide of change as a result of cliff erosion and related land and house loss. Scratby Coastal Erosion Group is a community group of local residents established to address this major issue on coastal change.

Ormesby Junior School had already planned to study coasts and erosion during this year’s summer term and so were very keen to be involved with Holding Back the Tide. And like other schools, they can envisage how their project and the topic of their local coast will be able to link in with other curriculum areas. ‘We want to use our locality as much as possible and being part of this project would give a real focus and purpose to this area of study for the children’ said Mrs D Whiting, School Head.

The Minister of State for the Environment, Phil Woolas, braved heavy showers to visit the village of Scratby in East Norfolk yesterday where coastal erosion is threatening 22 family homes within the next 2/3 years, and 150 in total in the longer term.

The visit was arranged by Member of Parliament Tony Wright, and the Minister met representatives from Erosion Groups from Scratby and nearby villages of Winterton and Hemsby. Members of the Great Yarmouth Borough Council and the Environment Agency were also in attendance.

The Minister was shown the problem by MP Tony Wright and Borough Councillors Jim Shrimplin and Charles Reynolds, and he expressed considerable interest, and asked numerous questions of those present to get a further insight into the problem.

Robert Stephenson of the Scratby Coastal Erosion Group, said that it was a great opportunity to discuss the situation at the ‘ highest level’, and that he is hopeful that on going talks between all parties will make further progress to secure the future of the community.

In the meantime the Scratby Coastal Erosion Group is in discussion with Great Yarmouth Borough Council regarding the project preparation for the rock berm extension from California to Newport.

Once this work has been carried out it will enable MP Tony Wright to press ahead to seek financial approval.

Allegations that dredging shingle from the North Sea to replenish Britain’s coastal defences is a waste of government money and counter-productive, are being studied by the National Audit Office.

The body, which normally focuses on effective use of national finances, has been asked to look at the effect of extracting gravel and sand from the seabed and to see whether it is causing widespread coastal erosion in East Anglia and Yorkshire. Continue reading “Watchdog called in over price of seabed dredging

Coastal erosion campaigners have hailed the efforts of a cross-party group of Norfolk MPs as “a whole chunk of England standing together saying we cannot let Norfolk go.”

Jim Bratton of Scratby’s coastal erosion group said Great Yarmouth MP Tony Wright had put the case for his stretch of coastline well at a commons debate broadcast live on Tuesday.

Mr Wright was one of a group of MPs who pledged to fight on after failing to win reassurances or concessions from the government over the mooted surrendering of 25 square miles of the county to the sea.

Environment minister Phil Woolas promised to visit the threatened area between Eccles and Winterton, but he glossed over an invitation by MP Norman Lamb officially to remove the highly controversial “worst case” sea defences option put forward by Natural England.

And he stressed in the Commons that “it is not the government’s policy to give compensation for the impact of floods and coastal erosion”.

Although Mr Bratton was disappointed by Mr Woolas’s “unsympathetic” response he was heartened by the debate which took local concerns to the highest level, adding “Mr Woolas can now be in no doubt about the widespread strength of feeling gathering pace.”

He said: “Tony put his point across very well about the flooding in Great Yarmouth and the erosion at Scratby. Afterall he has a coastline to worry about too although the emphasis has been on the whole of Norfolk. It was an opportunity for our area to be highlighted as well. With all but one of the Norfolk MPs saying the same thing it has to be a step forward because everyone is together.

“It’s a whole chunk of England standing together all speaking up and saying the same thing - we cannot let Norfolk go.”

Mr Woolas added that there was an obligation to answer the question of whether compensation should be provided “if damage has been caused by climate change rather than the natural processes of erosion or flooding”. But he did not answer it himself.

Figures released to the Countryside Alliance under the Freedom of Information Act have revealed that at least 14,434 new homes in the East are planned for construction on flood plains or in flood risk areas.

Forty local authorities in the East responded to the Freedom of Information request. A total of 293,542 new homes are planned of which 14,434 are in flood risk areas. The research followed the Government’s admission, last year, that it “does not collect centrally the number of houses planned for construction on flood plains”.

A spokesman said: “Climate change and the increasing frequency of major flooding have led the Government to address the risk of flooding for new development through the planning process. This does not, however, address the legacy of development proposed before the new policy.

“The Government needs to carry out a full audit of housing proposed for flood risk areas. The alternative is a time-bomb of thousands of un-insurable homes in the East under constant risk of flooding.”

At a recent meeting with Great Yarmouth Borough Council it was agreed, that in light of a letter recently received by our Member of Parliament Tony Wright from the Environment Agency, that preparatory work on the Scratby Rock Berm Extension project can now begin.

It is hoped that the project will be ready to be submitted to the Environment Agency when the next batch of finance is due to become available in 2011. Although there is no guarantee of approval, a viable project needs to be submitted to be given consideration.

There is also the possibility that the current criteria may change, or that more funds could be allocated to coastal defences before then.

In the meantime, the Coastal Erosion Group and the Borough Council are constantly monitoring beach changes and tidal conditions. Any comments or observations by local residents or visitors are always welcome.

Please call 01493 732142 or comment on our web site.

A LEADING coastal campaigner and a Norfolk MP will host a trio of meetings in the next two weeks to give the public a voice in the debate about the future of the northern Broads.

Proposals for the future of the waterways have already been discussed behind closed doors at a conference in Norwich on climate change, organised by Natural England and attended by representatives of the Environment Agency, Broads Authority and Norfolk County Council, plus other organisations.

Continue reading “Meetings will give the public a voice

On Wednesday February 20th Great Yarmouth Borough Council Cabinet agreed to accept the Shoreline Management Plan subject to certain conditions.

These include a change of status for Scratby beach from ‘no active intervention’ to ‘managed retreat’, thus enabling essential repairs to be carried out in the future to buy time to allow long term planning to be put in place.

In addition a social justice clause will be added to provide compensation to those adversley affected by coastal erosion in the future.

Continue reading “Response to Shoreline Management Plan acceptance

Two members of the Committee, John Bristo (Asst. Secretary) and Gerry Tucker (Webmaster), will be attending the Annual General Meeting of the All Party Parliamentary Group on Coastal and Marine Issues, at the Houses of Parliament on Wednesday, February 27th, 2008.

This follows an earlier attendance at an APPG meeting by committee members, Chris Szaj (Vice Chair) and Chris Hogg.

A full report will appear here shortly.

In other news, members of the committee will be meeting with CoastNet on Friday, February 29th, 2008 to discuss the Groups possible participation in the Holding Back The Tide project, a CoastNet initiative in the Essex Estuaries area (Mersea, Brightlingsea, Walton, Frinton); the Shotley Peninsula (Felixstowe, Harwich); Aldeburgh and Southwold and Lowestoft/Great Yarmouth.